Design Principles. Predator Case vs. JB Cases
Posted in The Journey on August 31st, 2010 by John BartonAn age old design principle is Form Follows Function. In other words when making something that is intended to be useful you should try to get the function right before designing the look of it.
Now of course some designers go for the "art" more than the function and that's all right as long as the consumer knows what they are getting. It's quite obvious that a Porsche Design toaster isn't as functional as a ToastMaster but the ToastMaster can toast ANYTHING perfectly. The Porsche Design one just LOOKS way more expensive (and is).
But what about when a company has a reputation for building products dedicated to function? Wouldn't you expect anything that they turn out to follow the basic rule?
Predator has become a famous name in the billiard world. They are everywhere, they sponsor everything, they are master marketers who manage to get their name on everyone and everything. They revolutionized the pool world with their spliced shafts effectively creating another segment of the industry all by themselves.
And the shafts work as advertised – for the most part. Of course SOME of the points are kind of marketingspeak for which no hard data to prove their claims has ever been shown. But their shafts have indeed sparked a host of competitors and forced cue makers across the board to rethink the way they build cues.
So when this company brings out a case wouldn't you think it would be the ultimate in performance? More efficient, lighter, stronger, more useful, most importantly more protective?
I would expect nothing less. But the cases that they brought out a few years ago are complete opposites of that. They are overbuilt monstrosities which are too big, too heavy, have weak closures which break easily, are not very protective and not very useful.
Harsh words. Especially coming from the man who designed the first generation of Predator cases. Am I bitter? Not at all. Right now my designs for mass production are the exclusive domain of Sterling Gaming. At the moment Sterling and Predator don't get along too well and that can change. It's entirely possible that I get the chance to design a new line for Predator at some point.
I understand how they ended up with what they have right now. Someone at Predator drew up some cool looking designs and they shipped those designs off to the Long Chan factory and Long Chan had zero clue how to make those designs into real products in the correct way so they just kept layering material until they ended up with something that resembled the pictures they were sent.
And Predator, having no other choice and being already committed to a new line of cases (it was time as well) went forward with a product that is really not up to their standards. To be fair the designs are appealing, they look pretty cool but the resulting product is crappy. Now that's harsh I know, but it's the truth. The sad part is that due to Predator's successful marketing now their new cases are also becoming some of the most copied, both as counterfeits and knockoffs of the general design.
Well anyway as it happens the other day I was out playing and I happened to put my case next to a Predator Blak 2×4. At first I didn't notice the disparity but then after a shot I was standing next to the cases and I could see how much bigger the Predator 2×4 is than my JB Case 3×6. It's taller (but does not handle more length), and bigger but does not have as much capacity.
And it's WAY heavier.
Here is a video comparing the two that I shot that day,